SCIENTIFIC AND TECHNICAL RESEARCH COMMITTEE ON SAFETY AND HEALTH IN EXTRACTIVE INDUSTRIES
Western medicine and the Chinese vision
Papers and debates, 18 November 1999
2nd part : Chinese medicine Qi gong
Summary

 
 CONCLUSION by M. COCUDE
 
M. Cocude

One shouldn't of course take any affirmation on qi gong at its face value but, as we have seen, scientific experiments can be carried out with it. We have taken good note of the différence between the qi gong you practice yourself (or under the guidance of an instructor) and qi gong practised by a therapeutist on a patient. We have learnt that, in China, only doctors can now practice it, which leaves it to be believed that, while therapeutic qi gong can be beneficial, it may also present risks.

Experimentation, whether it involves work on oneself or work with the projection of Qi, does not raise insuperable difficulties. There are methods to assess the psychological repercussions of a personal practice like concentration or the physiological impact (coherence of the brain waves). These methods have moreover been successfülly applied to test other oriental disciplines which arrived earlier in France, such as yoga and zen.

The cultural gap itself is not insuperable, provided it is borne in mind that support from. the subject is required more than elsewhere. This handicap can moreover be overcome by conducting animal experiments.

As for the applications, relaxation or well-being are put forward firstly: this is qi gong 'helping in everyday life'. A destressing factor, it can therefore be beneficial combined with any offier therapy because it is now known that stress weakens the immune defences.

That would be an explanation for its effects on the very wide range of pathologies seen in the bibliography; often, moreover, the iraprovements observed concern the subjective state of the patients as much as biological parameters which sometimes remain unchanged.

Tuming to pathologies, mention is to be made above all of its use in combating hypertension and senescence which are public health problems in France: one in two French people over 50 years old suffer from. hypertension and more and more of the population is growing older and therefore increasingly exposed to ageing diseases.

Qi gong is also worth being studied where western medicine is inoperative, which is the case with pneumoconiotics. We therefore sincerely hope pneumologies will take a close interest in this therapy.

 

Top of page
Next talk
Summary