SCIENTIFIC AND TECHNICAL RESEARCH COMMITTEE ON SAFETY AND HEALTH IN EXTRACTIVE INDUSTRIES
Western medicine and the Chinese vision
Papers and debates, 18 November 1999
1st part : Western medicine  
Summary

 
PRESENT RESEARCH AND PROSPECTS 
 
D. LAFON
The past twenty years have seen the appearance of many studies on the toxicity mechanisms of mineral particles. Silica and asbestos fibres have often served as models.

The discovery of new mechanistic hypotheses has helped study the effect of a large number of new molecules, either in prevention or treatment. Most of these studies have remained at the animal experimentation stage for the moment. A few clinical tests have however been made.

The mechanisms that have allowed this progress can be summarised as follows:

1 . Modification of the surface activity of mineral particles by the covering of their surface or a decrease in their capacity to generate oxygen radicals.

2. Increase in particular clearance.

3. Decrease in the activation of macrophages and the production of oxidants.

4. Decrease in the recruitment of inflammatory cells.

5. Decrease in the secretion of inflammation mediators.

6. Decrease in the secretion of growth factors

7. Decrease in collagen synthesis.

8. Decrease in cellular prolifération.

Three main categories of effects can summarise the action of the tested molecules.


1. Coverine of the surface sites of particies

These are the oldest treatinents. Aluminotherapy and the use of polyvinylpyridine-N-oxide gave rise to many experimental and clinical studies from 1970 to 1980.

The use of aluminium has been abandoned. PVNO is no longer used in European countries, which does not appear to, be the case in China.

Amiodarone has been used more recently, but this treatment was soon abandoned owing to its toxicity.

2. Protection aizainst oxidisiniz stress

Many molecules have been tested for ahnost ten years now: tetrandrine, ascorbic acid, 21-aminosteroid, superoxide dismutase, catalase, carotene and vitamin A, cyclic adenosine 3':5'-monophosphate (cAMP).

All these molecules have been tested only experimentally on animals.


3. Inflammatory response and inflammation mediators

Mineral particles activate macrophages which produce cytokines. The latter recruit polynuclear cells and monocytes.

Growth factors are secreted, inducing the prolifération of fibroblasts and the synthesis of collagen.

Anti-interleukin-1 antibodies, PNIN anti-rat antisera, anti-bFGFs, leukocytic anti-integrin antibodies CD 11 a and 11 b and anti-growth factor antibodies derived from platelets (PDGF) have thus been tested only experimentally on animals.

These studies are recent and many of them have been published in the past five years.

These publications as a whole show that a certain number of preventive or curative treatment leads are under study. The many mechanisms involved means that it is probably unlikely that a single treatment will be utilisable but it would be useful if studies were launched in the future on combined treatments.

The almost complete absence of research on this topic in Western Europe is to be observed, whereas countries such as China or eastern countries are highly present.

 


 Top of page
Next talk
Summary